Back to Homepage of Movielogy.com
 From Moviegoers for Moviegoers Please sign our guestbook & Share your opinions with the world Check out the New Movie Reviews
Reviews Menu
 
  Action
  Animation
  Comedy & Romantic
  Drama & Musical
  Epic
  Horror & Thriller
  Sci-Fi
  Superhero & Fantasy
 
Features Menu
 
  academy awards
  AFI 100 years
  golden globe
  rondo horror awards
  people's choice
  MTV movie awards
  Jiffest
  Indonesian Film Fests
  Razzie Awards
  Celebrity PROFILES
 
 
Box Office Menu
 
  Yearly
  All-Time!
  TOP 2007 DVD Sales
  TOP 2008 DVD Sales
 
Share/Save/Bookmark


City of Ember


U.S. 2008
Director: Gil Kenan
Cast: Saoirse Ronan, Harry Treadaway, Bill Murray
Release Date: October 10th 2008
Rating: PG
Running Time: 1 hour 35 minutes


The Movie Review

City of Ember film still 1
City of Ember film poster
CITY of EMBER
Storyline:3 stars
Cast:3 stars
Ending:2.5 stars
Overall:
3 stars

Something unknown always fascinates people, especially something beneath the soil that we are standing on right now. Several months before, we have watched an underground world in Journey to the Center of the Earth. With City of Ember, there is slight differences, although both movies are based on novels, but City of Ember is not full of fantasy since it's about saving human races by putting them in an underground town.

City of Ember is based on a novel written by Jeanne Duprau. It mainly focuses on Lina Mayfleet (Saoirse Ronan) and Doon Harrow (Harry Treadaway) who suspects that there may be a way out of Ember. Why do they want to get out? Because the City of Ember's main source of light and energy comes from the generator which cannot be longer counted on. Lucky for the 12-year-old clever Lina when she finds out about the box that has been passed on from the first mayor to the next until the box is abandoned in Lina's closet.

People of Ember are actually worry of the blackouts which the last one always last longer than the previous one. Lina and Doon try to solve the mystery written on the decaying paper found in the box, but the coward Mayor Cole (Bill Murray), instead of helping the kids, tries to own the box mainly for himself. Now Lina and Doon have to race against clock and Cole's men before the City of Ember endures blackout for good.

One of the reasons I watched City of Ember was because of wanting to see how Saoirse Ronan performs in this fantasy movie. Well this is not her best performance as we saw in Atonement, that I can assure you. However this soon to be 15-year-old actress still gives good performance. The rest of the cast's performances is just mere mediocre to good, since Bill Murray's script arguably limits him for giving his best.

City of Ember actually has top notch premise, it's just that the adventure side is not explored enough. And it's a waste that the concept of an underground city is not portrayed as majestic as posible. I gotta say that the planology of the City of Ember is kinda boring. But when the action kicks in, the fun begins, too bad that none of them are of novelty.

City of Ember film still 2 City of Ember film still 3 City of Ember film still 4

© iwan pranowo of Movielogy.com
 

   Home > Superhero & Fantasy Home > City of Ember


City of Ember Trailer


Back to Top



Movielogy Exclusives Menu
 
  Classic Movies
  Asian Movies
  Indonesian Movies
 
 
Home About & Contact Policy & Disclaimer Links Advertise with Us Site Map
Contents & Designs © 2008-Present Movielogy.com -- Iwan Pranowo